Property valuation of N 8th Street, Philadelphia, PA: 5045, 5046, 5047, 5048, 5049, 5050, 5051, 5052, 5053, 5054 (tax assessments)
Other nearby streets: N 8th Street (1) 
N 8th Street (2)
N 8th Street (3)
N 8th Street (4)
N 8th Street (5)
N 8th Street (2)
N 8th Street (3)
N 8th Street (4)
N 8th Street (5)
Listed properties vs overall distribution of properties in Philadelphia, PA:
Advertisements
5045 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: MARTIN NUNEZ SR
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $37,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/18/2012
Sale type: Closer review of sale completed. Sale determined to be good, bona fide and at arms length
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: MARTIN NUNEZ SR
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $37,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/18/2012
Sale type: Closer review of sale completed. Sale determined to be good, bona fide and at arms length
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5046 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CHARLENE M TRST JACKSON NADIA JACKSON ETAL
Assessed land value: $8,198 (it was $1,916 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,802 (it was $7,524 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $92,000 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $92,000
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 05/06/1993
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 16 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,464 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,616 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CHARLENE M TRST JACKSON NADIA JACKSON ETAL
Assessed land value: $8,198 (it was $1,916 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,802 (it was $7,524 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $92,000 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $92,000
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 05/06/1993
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 16 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,464 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,616 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5047 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: ANGELA ALEXANDER
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $38,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/31/1994
Sale type: Sale deferred for closer review by Evaluation staff
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: ANGELA ALEXANDER
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $38,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/31/1994
Sale type: Sale deferred for closer review by Evaluation staff
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5048 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CHRISTOPHER LYON MUHAMMAD
Assessed land value: $8,198 (it was $1,915 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,702 (it was $7,525 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $91,900 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $91,900
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 10/02/2008
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 16 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,464 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CHRISTOPHER LYON MUHAMMAD
Assessed land value: $8,198 (it was $1,915 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,702 (it was $7,525 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $91,900 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $91,900
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 10/02/2008
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 16 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,464 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5049 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CARLTON L VILLS
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $9,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/28/1991
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: CARLTON L VILLS
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $9,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/28/1991
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5050 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: MICHAEL SIDHOM
Assessed land value: $7,901 (it was $1,776 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $89,199 (it was $8,208 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $97,100 (it was $9,984 in 2009)
Market value: $97,100
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $34,000
Date the deed was transferred: 03/31/2009
Sale type: Closer review of sale completed. Sale determined to be good, bona fide and at arms length
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Hotels and Apartments
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
View: Typical
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Floor plan: Duplex (converted)
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: MICHAEL SIDHOM
Assessed land value: $7,901 (it was $1,776 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $89,199 (it was $8,208 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $97,100 (it was $9,984 in 2009)
Market value: $97,100
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $34,000
Date the deed was transferred: 03/31/2009
Sale type: Closer review of sale completed. Sale determined to be good, bona fide and at arms length
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Hotels and Apartments
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
View: Typical
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Floor plan: Duplex (converted)
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5051 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: JOHN E DAWSON
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $19,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/01/1985
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: JOHN E DAWSON
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $19,000
Date the deed was transferred: 10/01/1985
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5052 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: SHERMEKA CORE
Assessed land value: $8,132 (it was $1,916 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,968 (it was $7,524 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $92,100 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $92,100
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $49,900
Date the deed was transferred: 11/14/2001
Sale type: Others, for some reason does not meet the criteria in the definition of market value
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: None
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,624 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: SHERMEKA CORE
Assessed land value: $8,132 (it was $1,916 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $83,968 (it was $7,524 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $92,100 (it was $9,440 in 2009)
Market value: $92,100
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $49,900
Date the deed was transferred: 11/14/2001
Sale type: Others, for some reason does not meet the criteria in the definition of market value
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: None
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,624 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5053 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: JAMES SPINKS
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $3
Date the deed was transferred: 03/16/2009
Sale type: Sale deferred for closer review by Evaluation staff
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: JAMES SPINKS
Assessed land value: $4,848 (it was $1,602 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $75,752 (it was $7,134 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $80,600 (it was $8,736 in 2009)
Market value: $80,600
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $3
Date the deed was transferred: 03/16/2009
Sale type: Sale deferred for closer review by Evaluation staff
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15 feet
Depth: 63.36 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/10/2011
Exterior condition: Average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 6
Number of bedrooms: 3
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 950.54 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,092 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
5054 N 8th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: RONALD J PIEDRA BERNARD PIEDRA
Assessed land value: $8,132 (it was $2,007 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $48,868 (it was $7,881 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $57,000 (it was $9,888 in 2009)
Market value: $57,000
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 11/22/2013
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/16/2011
Exterior condition: Below average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Philadelphia, PA 19120
Find on map >>
Owner: RONALD J PIEDRA BERNARD PIEDRA
Assessed land value: $8,132 (it was $2,007 in 2009)
Assessed building value: $48,868 (it was $7,881 in 2009)
Total assessed value for property: $57,000 (it was $9,888 in 2009)
Market value: $57,000
Date of last market value change: 01/2013
Sale price: $1
Date the deed was transferred: 11/22/2013
Sale type: Sales between related parties, i.e. Grantor/Grantee, Owner/Tenant
Status of construction: Finished
Category: Residential
Site type: Inside location on the block
Frontage: 15.86 feet
Depth: 91.50 feet
Shape: Rectangular
Topography: Street level
Garage type: Basement Garage
Number of sheltered parking spaces: 1
View: Typical
Number of stories: 2
Date the exterior condition was observed: 11/16/2011
Exterior condition: Below average
Year property was built: 1935 (estimated)
Number of rooms: 7
Number of bedrooms: 4
Number of bathrooms: 1
Basement type: Partial with 1 or more finished areas
Type of heater or heating system: Undetermined
Connection to sewer: Yes
Land area: 1,452.09 square feet
Total dwelling livable area: 1,604 square feet
Assessments for tax year: 2014
Other nearby streets: N 8th Street (1)
N 8th Street (2)
N 8th Street (3)
N 8th Street (4)
N 8th Street (5)
N 8th Street (2)
N 8th Street (3)
N 8th Street (4)
N 8th Street (5)
Recent posts about Philadelphia, Pennsylvania on our local forum with over 2,400,000 registered users. Philadelphia is mentioned 39,635 times on our forum:
Settings
X
Recently Added Photos
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia, PA
Request disassociating your name from street-level assessment address
Recent home sales, price trends, and home value evaluator powered by Onboard Informatics
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Some parts © 2024 Advameg, Inc.
Compilation, repackaging, or reproduction prohibited. Users are forewarned that it is incumbent upon them to verify information with the responsible state agency. Advameg, Inc. does not guarantee the data presented is up-to-date nor does it assume responsibility for updating it. Therefore any names, owners or addresses may have changed. Use of any information published here to contact the persons might be prohibited by the law.